PUR VS Brita | Which is Better

PUR VS Brita has always been the most popular comparison of all times on water pitcher and faucet filters. Two of the company has been competing for the crown of “Best Sellers” on Amazon.

Let’s talk a little bit about the background of two companies.

 

Background


PUR, an American based company which has more than 30 years of experience in developing water treatment products.

This includes water filter pitchers, faucet-mounted, dispenser, and filters for Kenmore refrigerator. Their products are sold over 33 countries in the world.

Brita, on the other hand, is a German-based water filter company which has been in the business since 1966.

Their product includes water filter pitchers, dispensers, faucet-mounted filters and filtered water bottle. Their business has expanded to 66 countries around the globe which is doubled compared to PUR.

 

Both companies claimed that their product does not PURIFY water and will only provide a certain level of filtering on water contaminants.

 

Product Comparison


Among all the products from these two companies, we have 2 particular product categories that they are competing.

  1. Water filter pitchers, dispensers
  2. Faucet-Mounted Filter

Both companies invested heavily in developing and innovate water filter solutions in these two categories to make it more affordable and effective.

The initial cost of these two products is less than $50 which is the entry level of water filtration.

Just how good are these filters. Let’s take a look at the individual comparison.

 

Water Filter Pitcher/ Dispenser Comparison


Water filter jugs are always one of the best ways to filter contaminants in water.

It is lightweight, portable, and compact which you can store it in the fridge or put it on the dining table.

As such, the pitcher is one of the favorite water filter product by people who are renting a house or college students staying in dorms.

I bet you have already settled with either Brita or PUR as your first water pitcher.

Let’s compare it in 4 different aspects.

1. Filtration Quality

For every water filter system, the heart of it is the filtration cartridges. The appearance has little or no impact on the system.

Brita has 3 different cartridges while PUR only has 2 which can be used across their pitchers.

PUR and Brita Pitcher Filter Cartridge

Let’s take a look at the capability of those 5 filter cartridges that claimed by the respective company.

Filter CartridgeContaminants ReductionMaterial
Brita Standard FilterRemoves chlorine, mercury, carbon, cadmium, and zincActivated carbon granules and Ion Exchange Resin
Brita Stream FilterRemoves chlorine, mercury, carbon, cadmium, and zincDual-layer activation carbon filter
Brita Longlast FilterRemoves everything from standard filter plus 99.9% of lead, class 1 particulate, benzene and asbestosActivated Carbon Granules with Ion Exchange resin and Lead absorbents media.
PUR Basic FilterReduce mercury (95%), chlorine (97.5%), Zinc (86%), Class 1 Particulate(99%)Activated carbon filters with ion exchange material.
PUR Lead FilterReduce mercury (95%), chlorine (97.5%), Zinc (86%), Class 1 Particulate(99%), Lead (99.9%)Activated carbon filters with ion exchange material and Lead reduction media

From the comparison table above, we can see that the cartridges from both companies are removing more or less the same contaminants.

Winner: The cartridges from both companies perform practically well in this sense. Couldn’t identify the winner based on this case. 

2. Design and Models

While Brita has been in the market longer than PUR, it has much more varieties as compare to PUR.

Let’s start with PUR. 

PUR have 4 different models of the pitcher spanning across the 7 and 10 cup pitcher. The features include:PUR Water filter Pitcher

  1. 3 out of 4 of the models comes with LED indicator for filter lifespan.
  2. All the models are equipped with the easy-fill lid.

It is a simple and basic functionality for a pitcher to perform the filtration. Nothing fancy.

Dispenser: It comes with 2 models of 18 cup dispenser too which is compatible to the filter cartridge that is used by the pitcher.

Fancy Design By Brita

On the other hand, Brita has more than 15 pitchers and dispenser model available in the market.

As once said, you sure will find a suitable model in Brita. 🙂

Here are some of the features on the Brita Pitcher.Brita Stream Filter Pitcher

  1. 5-12 cups of water pitcher across more than 15 models.
  2. Filter-On-The-Go technology on selected models to filter as you.
  3. Most of the pitcher comes with an electronic filter indicator.
  4. Additional features such as WIFI connected, auto-fill lid and stainless steel body available on selected models

There are different functionality which will suit everyone’s needs and requirement of a water filter jug.

Dispenser: Similar to PUR, it comes with an 18 cup dispenser that uses the same filter cartridge as the pitcher.

Winner: Brita has a slight advantage in terms of designs and the choices available to the market. 

3. Lifespan and Maintenance Cost

As what we always mentioned in our post, the lifespan of the filter reflects how great and innovative the company is.

A longer lifespan filter can reduce the frequency of replacement and reduce the maintenance cost of the system.

It is better to understand how much that you will be paying every year rather than just considering the initial investment of the system.

PUR Filtration Cartridge: 

  1. PUR Basic Filter: 40 Gallons, up to 2 months for 2 person usage.
  2. PUR Lead Filter: 30 Gallons, up to 2 months for 2 person usage.

Annual Maintenance Cost: $36(Basic Filter),  $60(Lead Filter)

Brita Filtration Cartridge: 

  1. Brita Standard Filter: 40 Gallons, up to 2 months for 2 person usage.
  2. Brita Stream Filter: 40 Gallons, up to 2 months for 2 person usage.
  3. Brita Longlast Filter: 120 Gallons, up to 6 months for 2 person usage

Annual Maintenance Cost: $33(Standard and Longlast Filter),  $40(Stream Filter)

Winner: Brita is clearly cheaper and more sustainable in terms of lifespan and the annual running cost to maintain the performance of the system. 

4. Customer Reviews and Complaints

Reviews

Both filtration systems receive and above average reviews from it’s existing customers from Amazon.

Brita has about 1400 reviews with an average rating of 4.1 over 5 while PUR has about 600 reviews with an average rating of 3.9 over 5.

WorldOfWaterFilter gave a 3.9 on Brita Pitcher and 3.7 on PUR pitcher based on our 5 unique review criteria.

Complaints

Both companies’ pitcher received complaints on the body quality of the pitcher, but it is only a fraction of it.

It is merely a production quality control issue where it impacts a small portion of the customers.

Winner: Brita has a leading edge in terms of customer satisfaction and product effectiveness. 

Summary: PROS and CONS

Let’s summarize the findings of both pitchers with the PROS and CONS.

Brita Everyday Pitcher

Brita Pitcher

PROS
– Long Lasting Filter
– Cheaper Initial and Maintenance Cost
– More Selection of Choices
– Excellent Review From Customers
CONS
– 30 Days Money Back Guaranteed
– Bad Quality Control

Get yourself this Brita Pitcher today. It is one of the best seller basic water pitcher.

Buy-Now-Amazon

Brita 10 Cup Everyday Pitcher, Best Seller!!

 

PUR Water filter Pitcher

PUR Pitcher

PROS
– 90 Days Warranty.
– Affordable Initial Cost.
– Excellent Review From Customers
CONS
– Short Lifespan Filter
– Slightly Expensive maintenance cost
– Bad Quality Control

Alternatively, you can still check out the reviews on PUR 11 Cup Classic Pitcher and compare it with the Brita Everyday.

Buy-Now-Amazon

PUR 11 Cup Classic Filtration Pitcher

 

Our Verdict and Winners: BRITA

With all 4 of the criteria above, in an overall view, Brita is leading in the pitcher’s field compare to PUR.

Even the Amazon leading chart also shows the choice of the consumers towards the water filter pitcher category is leading toward Brita.

Amazon Best Seller Pitcher

While it might be a personal choice, I would definitely recommend Brita instead of PUR for water filter pitchers.

BONUS Recommendation: 

Looking for another alternative rather than just PUR vs Brita? Check out Aquagear pitcher. It is one of our top recommended pitcher that has better filtering and a LIFETIME WARRANTY.

 

Faucet-Mounted Filter Comparison


The faucet-mounted filter is one of the most compact and easiest installation filter that is available in the market.

There is no complicated tubing, canister filter and drilling is required in order to make it work. All you need is a compatible faucet!

As you can see from Amazon’s bestseller list, Brita and PUR are competing for the first spot (exclude the cartridge replacement by Culligan).

Amazon Best Seller Faucet Filter

Let’s use the 4 aspects above to determine which faucet filter is better than the other.

1. Filtration Quality:

First up, let’s explore the individual filtration cartridge from both companies on the faucet filter category.

Brita only has a single type of filter cartridge while PUR has 2 different types of filter cartridges.

Here is the specification that was CLAIMED by the respective company.

Filter CartridgeContamination ReductionMaterial
Brita Faucet FilterRemove 99% of lead.
Reduce chlorine taste and odor, benzene, asbestos, trichloroethylene
Single stage activated carbon filter.
PUR Basic FilterRemoves 99% of lead, mercury, cysts, pesticides, chlorine and sediment.Sediment Trap Filter and Activated Carbon Media
PUR MineralClear FilterSame as Basic Filter.
Add a crisp taste to the water.
Sediment Trap Filter, Activated Carbon Media and Post Filter

From the comparison above, we can clearly see that the basic filters from both companies are a close fight. What sets that apart is the MineralClear filter by PUR which made the water tastier.

NSF Certified: Both filters are certified against NSF/ANSI standard 53 and 42 and 401 for reducing lead, chlorine and many other contaminants.

Winner: For this reason, PUR has the reason the claim the title for filtration quality of faucet filter cartridge. 

2. Design and Models

Unlike water pitcher, PUR and Brita only have a handful of models on the faucet filter category.

There isn’t a lot of fancy features been introduced by both companies.

3 Brita Filter

Brita comes with 3 different models which use the same filtration cartridge.

3 Brita Faucet Filter Model

Here are some of the features available on the system.

  1. All models come with a LED lifespan indicator.
  2. The advanced model comes with 3 different water flow selections.

4 PUR Filter

PUR however, have more additional features as compared to Brita in this category.

PUR Faucet Filter Type

Here are some main features of the faucet filter series by PUR.

  1. LED Light indicator for all models.
  2. Bluetooth tracker available to track the usage of water in real time.
  3. Vertical and horizontal filtration systems available at your choice.

Except for the chrome model, all the faucet filter are built with BPA free plastic.

Winner: PUR has a great and innovative design which put it at the top of the list. 

3. Lifespan and Maintenance Cost

The lifespan of filtration will have a direct impact on the annual maintenance cost of the system.

On average, a great faucet-mounted filter will last for 100 gallons per single filter. Let see how do PUR and Brita perform.

PUR Filtration Cartridge: Pur Filter Cartridge 3 pack Box

  1. PUR Basic Filter: 100 Gallons, up to 2-3 months.
  2. PUR MineralClear Filter: 100 Gallons, up to 2-3 months.

Annual Maintenance Cost: $51(Basic Filter),  $54(MineralClear Filter)

That would be a good choice to upgrade to a MineralClear filter as it is only $3 difference per year! 🙂

Brita Filtration Cartridge: 

  1. Brita Faucet Filter: 100 Gallons, up to 2-3 months.

Annual Maintenance Cost: $78

Winner: In terms of affordability, PUR is much more affordable as compared to Brita. You wouldn’t know the running cost from the initial pricing of the product until you calculated it. 

4. Customer Reviews and Complaints

Reviews

Both faucet filter systems receive average reviews from it’s existing customers from Amazon.

Brita has about 500 reviews with an average rating of 3.8 over 5 while PUR has about 1500 reviews with an average rating of 3.4 over 5.

WorldOfWaterFilter gave a 3.9 on PUR faucet filter and 3.6 on Brita faucet Filter our own review criteria.

Complaints

Likewise, both companies received complaints on the body quality issue.

This quality issue occurs in the water pitcher for both companies where it only impacts a small portion of its customers.

There are only a fraction of customers that have this issue and apparently, PUR has more issue as compared to Brita.

Winner: Brita is more satisfactory as rated by it’s existing customers.

Summary: PROS and CONS

Let’s summarize the findings of both faucet filters with the PROS and CONS.

Brita Advanced Faucet Filter

Brita Faucet Filter

PROS
– Long Lasting Filter
– 1 Year Limited Warranty
– Certified Against NSF
CONS
– Average review from existing customer
– Expensive Maintenance Cost
– Bad Quality Issues

Get yourself this Brita Faucet Filter today with Amazon. Discover what the customer says about this product.

Buy-Now-Amazon

Brita Advanced Faucet Filtration System 

 

Pur PFM400H Faucet Water Filter

PUR Faucet Filter

PROS
– 2 Years Warranty.
– Affordable Filter Maintenance.
– Remove up to 99% of 70 contaminants.
– Long Lifespan Filter

CONS
– Average Review by Customers.
– Bad Quality Issues

To get yourself a PUR faucet filter, click on the link below to purchase it from Amazon.

Buy-Now-Amazon

PUR Bluetooth Ultimate Faucet Filtration System

 

Our Verdict and Winners: PUR

It is quite obvious that PUR is the winner in this category. The filtration quality, additional functionality and filter cost, and lifespan is way better than Brita.

Brita may have dominated the pitcher market, but PUR did a good job in securing the market share of the faucet filters.

However, both company should need work on solving their quality issues.

BONUS Recommendation: 

Why don’t you get one of those stainless steel faucet filter to avoid leaky plastic designs? Wingsol is one of our recommended stainless steel faucet filters.

 

Conclusion


There is always good and bad in the same brand in a different category. In Worldofwaterfilter, we recommend products regardless of brands. We will only recommend a great filtration system for our readers.

Leave a comment below if you still have any doubts on our PUR VS Brita comparison. We are glad to assist you on this matter.

Leave a Comment